As I look at these guys and their careers, I believe that all of them are deserving of being in the Hall of Fame. Think about the title for a second... Hall of FAME. Regardless of what these guys may or may not have done as far as Performance Enhancing Drugs are concerned, They were undoubtedly the most FAMOUS players of their era. These guys also began their careers prior to the "Steroid Era" and had marked success in those seasons. If I were to vote on this ballot, I would base my votes upon star-power and numbers. This is how I would break it down:
Roger Clemens: In. I would vote Roger Clemens in for a number of reasons, although I can also see the myriad of reasons that would keep him out. Clemens amassed 180+ wins prior to his years in Toronto. I use Toronto as a barrier, as the two years he was there is said to be the time when he began using performance enhancing drugs. Before Toronto, Clemens earned three Cy Young Awards, One MVP award, and also had a dominant 1990 season where he went 21-6 with a 1.93 ERA. Based on these numbers alone, Clemens has the numbers to belong in the Hall. Including post-Toronto numbers may weaken his case for some voters, but I still believe that regardless of PED use, he was one of the biggest stars of his era and should be recognized as such.
Sammy Sosa: Out. Sammy Sosa was not a complete enough player in my opinion. His power and RBI numbers were out of this world in the late 90's and early 2000's, which will probably get him close to induction if voters look past steroid allegations. No gold gloves, no batting titles, and only one disputable MVP award are what keeps him out in my opinion. I look for a complete star, and Sammy Sosa just didnt really do it for me.
Barry Bonds: In. Being the most notorious player in the game, his rapport (or lack thereof) with the same baseball writers who hold his chances of induction in their hands will likely hurt him. Lets look at the numbers, pre-2001. 495 Home Runs, 471 stolen bases, 3 MVP awards, 8 Gold Gloves, and 8 Silver Slugger awards. There are guys that are in the Hall right now that do not have those numbers, and that was only the front half of his career. Say what you want about whether he really knowingly took PED's or not, but look at what the guy did for the game at the peak of his career. He sold out opposing ballparks, caused pitchers, pitching coaches, and managers to lose their minds over how well he could dissect pitchers, and also became the single-season and career home run king, whether people like it or not. He won two batting titles later in his career, not because he hit home runs, but because he made the most out of his at-bats. The same baseball writers that voted him to 7 MVP awards now must acknowledge that this man belongs in the Hall of Fame.
Other players I think are deserving of garnering serious votes on this ballot are Morris, Biggio, Piazza, Bagwell, and Palmeiro.
The fact of the matter is this. The fans, as well as the baseball writers loved the game during this era. These men put butts in seats, and gave writers something to write about every day. What kind of double standard would it be for those same writers who voted on those countless accolades to now go back and keep these players who helped them stay employed out of the Hall of Fame?

No comments:
Post a Comment